The
role of women in education and in life in general is so versatile that say
about it in “two words” is impossible. A woman can be the inspiration, an
assistant and a wise counselor who can direct in time, with a smile she can
help to overcome some issues between relations within the group. Men are not
strong in this, so it is good that a lot of women in education. Everything
would be a lot tougher if education as in the XIX century was dominated by men.
In
general, I think there is no big difference between women leadership in
different countries. For example, as was described in Grogan et.al (2011) that
many women leaders used their mothering skills like nurturing, organizing,
motivating and listening and these skills are beneficial for leadership (p.85).
The mothering skills most associated with female leadership is attention to
relationships, encouragement, protection and support “we often hear how women
connect their work in schools to their work at home, how they care for and
protect their own children compared to the ways they have chosen to lead”
(Grogan, 2011). I found this as one of the connections to the Kazakhstani
context of women leadership. In our country most women teachers and leaders
care about everything they have, either at home or at work. The most important
that women can listen not only issues about work but about personal issues as
well and they find time to give an advice.
Another
connection to our context that I found in Grogan’s article is that men work
more often to meet their own needs, such as success, achievement, money and
winning. While women are “more likely to put the needs of the organization, or
children, or learning ahead of their personal goals” (Grogan, 2011). This
statement shows that women leadership is effective in many ways and it is not
different from our context. Certainly, women also want those things as men want
but in Kazakhstan most women are married and it is normal that husband earns
money and looks for promotion. Thus, there is an opportunity for women to devote
themselves to work for success and prosperity of the institution.
In
conclusion, women leadership skills and approaches which described in Grogan’s
article are connected to Kazakhstani context in many ways. In particular,
having mothering skills, care about their work, sacrifice to improve or change
something these all abilities exist in the leadership approaches among women in
Kazakhstan. In my opinion, women around the world show and prove their
effective ability to lead. Moreover, women are less likely competing between
themselves but controversially they try to unite people and make this world
more kind.
Reference
Grogan, M., Shakeshaft, C. (2011). Women and educational leadership
(Vol. 5). John Wiley&Sons.
Thank you, Aizhan for this interesting blog! You raise the issue which is significantly relevant and debatable one in our country. I suppose that the female leadership in education in Kazakhstan and all over the world has both differences and commonalities as well. Similarities are as following: the desire to improve the situation, introduce changes, provide support for the working team, give advice and so on. While different points, in my opinion, related to cultural-traditional aspect. In Kazakhstan, it is traditionally considered that girls first of all mothers and they should primarily think about family, not about job and career. While in some countries, women tend to think firstly about career achievements and then family.However, as the world changes there are some transformations and shifts. Now we can see women in our country who successfully juggle career with family.
ReplyDeleteOstensibly, women are significant contributors to their nations. They are one of the powerful existences throughout the history. For example, women can do several things simultaneously: take care of their children, looking after their parents, washing, cooking and working. All these mentioned indicators are one of good leader’s characteristics. Moreover, they advocate for education, peace and new opportunities for their children. From my point of view, in order to give good knowledge, first of all they should be acknowledged about it. Thus, women should be educated whether living in Kazakhstan or not.
ReplyDeleteDear Aizhan,
ReplyDeleteI remember the hot disscussions about this issue in our Leadership and Management classes.I absolutelly agree that men's and women's leadership approaches are different. Men prefer totalitarism,whereas women use democratic ways more. Overall the role of women in Kazakhstan is changing. Before women were caregivers and mothers,but now they are breadwinners too.
So there is a need to develop leadership skills in order to be competative in "men's world". I believe that if all presidents of the countries were a women there will be no war in the world.