Once together with my groupmates we were discussing the issue of gender defining. This topic brought a great discussion then, later I saw the post of Ainur J on sex education at school. As a Primary School English teacher, I find this topic really interesting because our childhood beliefs reflect in our adulthood decisions. Apart from Ainur J, I would like to share my thought about the definition of gender, its importance and impact on life, and the influence of social context on it.
I see the meaning of the term ‘gender’ as something which was given to us in birth and was educated by people we were surrounded by (their beliefs and attitudes). While people feel fine with what was given to them, they achieve and keep soul balance which allows and sometimes even inspires them to live, study, work, create, develop themselves, bring up children, etc. Imbalance takes place when people deny their nature, they feel that their sexual characteristics hinder and/or limit their opportunities. However, what people tend to aim at during their life is gaining harmony and agreement with themselves. This means that if a person was biologically born as a girl and she accepts that - she feels balanced; but if this girl refuses and claims herself as a male or the third gender, she is bound to have personal conflicts which bother her all the time and, consequently, she will probably spend a lot of her precious time and force to disagree with society. The same thing is likely to happen to a boy.
I believe that sometimes the society makes up criteria for determining gender like toys for boys and girls. This helps keep the balance in the world: historically, a man is a person responsible for material things and a woman is for abstract ones (atmosphere at home, care after family, etc.). However, some people take radical sides and start creating and/or following stereotypes according to which a woman can’t work or a man can’t stay with children. In fact, both of them can do everything they want to, but they shouldn't forget that naturally they are a woman and a man.
Personally, I am really thankful to my parents for accepting my gender and bringing up me as a girl. To do so, they bought me girlish toys such as a Barbie, iron, and cooker, told me beautiful stories about princesses, and showed a lot of Disney cartoons about them. Also, I remember a book called “Everything a girl needs to know” given for my birthday. Now it seems to me a little bit foolish, but it included a lot of useful information on etiquette, clothes design, cooking, and so on. So, my parents did their best to equip me with all those things which could be useful to me as to a person who was born female. At the same time, I remember my LEGO, bycicle, mini-copies of cars which didn’t make me feel I am a boy even if I liked them.
I think our discussion was really interesting to me because I wouldn't have thought about the mechanisms of defining gender. It made me think of such people who find themselves as LGTB. Gender education is really important; however, it shouldn't be involved as a separate subject but some elements of it could be implemented in education process. For example, separation of girls for PT lessons and Craft, grouping students so that each of them can take their gender roles (games like “Desert Island”).
I am sure it will be reasonable to share our experiences before we start the discussion on the necessity of sex education at schools. So, what do you think about the issue of defining the gender? How important is it to define oneself as male or female? What has influenced you in this process?
Dear Darina!
ReplyDeleteThank you very much for sharing your personal experience and raising such a burning issue in education!
The great importance gender defining plays in society as it impacts on the future life of a child. Even while upbringing a child parents force their children to follow the stereotypes which are consented in society. The examples of gender inequality we could overview around the world, when women are less likely to participate in public life as men do, women are treated to bear a reproductive role to raise children and to do household tasks, while men are valued in society more. That led to the feminist idea of gender inequality and discrimination. So. there is a huge need to bring up our children with the understanding of their gender.
Mariyam, I believe I see your point. And I am really glad that you understand what I am talking about.
DeleteStereotypes are extreme points, whereas I am talking about balance. Therefore, parents as adult people probably need some help in this issue in order to prevent gender inequality and discrimination cases.
What I want to say is that a girl should be brought up as a girl in order to equip her with knowledge which will be useful for her as a lady/woman/mother. This girl can take any position at work, but she will act like a person who has no doubts about her gender. As well as a boy educated as gentleman/man/father.
Darina, I appreciate your willingness to tackle such a difficult topic. Gender, especially once seen as a social construct, can be a divisive issue as cultural beliefs are deep and personal. I, for one, don't think that boys should be taught how to be boys and vice versa for girls. Take Finnish and Swedish languages for example, who are moving toward a more gender-neutral society. Some food for thought...
ReplyDeletehttp://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/worldviews/wp/2015/04/01/sweden-is-about-to-add-a-gender-neutral-pronoun-to-its-official-dictionary/
This comment has been removed by the author.
DeletePhil, I followed the link and I can say that in Kazakh language there is the same pronoun for male and female. However, I am sure there are some other reasons in contrast to LGBT promotion in Sweden.
DeleteI don't think gender-neutral society is a good idea because then children start hesitating about their gender which is indispensable part of personal identity, but there are so many other things children have to worry about while they are growing up. By actions like this adults make children worry.
Phil, neither do I believe that children should be taught how to be boys / girls because it is what they will learn themselves later. My position is that boys need other skills when they get older apart from girls. As an example, I am sure that craft lessons when boys are taught to make furniture while girls - to knit,cook and sew are really useful. Of course, not everyone will need to practise all of these, but it teaches children be responsible for what they do/make on their own.
What I want to say is that accepting your gender is pivotal and the society should do their best to help understand it and keep the balance.
Thank you, Darina, for this interesting post.
DeleteForm my understanding gender is the norms of how males and females should behave, speak, think, dress within a society. And these norms were created by society. Hence, there are some expectations of the gender roles. Throughout the lifespan males and females learn of their roles from parents, media, books, religion, workplace, etc. As you mentioned above parents tend to treat and raise their daughters and sons differently. Fathers tend to teach their sons more physical work, how to be strong and decisive; while mothers usually prepare their daughters for household work.
These norms are not good or bad; they just exist. However, those people who do not follow these norms usually face discrimination and violence. Nevertheless, today these norms vary according to time and a society.
Dear Darina,
ReplyDeleteThis gender issue is such a bothering topic for all these days.
What I mostly disagree with is the reason for us to argue with the Creator? With these kind of beliefs we will one day stop accepting the differencies between men and women and the third gender in between will be born. Why would anyone argue about reproductive need for women? This is just a bit beyond my understanding. What I think though, is that while accepting the differences and similarities we should not concentrate on the gender itslef we should better think of the input people could bring. There seems to be little reason for dividing these schools/ methods are for girls and these for boys. I think we better accept these natural roles and think how I am as a man/woman helpful for this kind of work? and here, it is not necessary to pretend be a man/woman with a thought that men are better than women or vice versa.
Hi, Darina
ReplyDeleteThis was one of the hottest topic in Aisi Li's course. Actually, we had been discussing the issue of woman discrimination, but we touched above-mentioned topic as well. The first thing, I would like to pay your attention is that "gender" and "sex" have different meanings. As far as I remembered, sex - it is about the biological characteristics of people, while gender is mostly sociological terms, as some commentators mentioned, how to behave and act in definite society.
Honestly, I do not agree with you and with most people above. We are living in a new society and should become open-minded for everything, particularly to accept other people's choices. If a person was born as a male (which is defined as a "sex"), however due to some psychological aspects he does not accept his social duties and want to be a different (which is defined as a "gender") we have to accept his decision and respect him despite this facts, but for his personal qualities. I am for the liberty from social stigmas. Everyone is unique and it is (mostly) not our duties to tell them who they are and how they should behave or act. It is my personal viewpoint, sorry if I wound you somehow. Hope my comment will give you food for thoughts